Postponing termination date not unfair dismissal

  • Employment Tribunal
a female worker with her head in her hands
Peninsula Logo

Peninsula Group, HR and Health & Safety Experts

(Last updated )

The Employment Appeal Tribunal (EAT) had to consider whether the repeated postponement of a claimant’s termination date was an unfair dismissal.

The claimant was absent from work due to an illness for a lengthy period and the respondent decided to terminate his contract of employment on 31st August 2017 to take effect on 5th January 2018.

The respondent, however, decided to extend the termination date on a total of seven occasions. The effective date of termination ultimately was 21st December 2018. The termination date was postponed so that further medical information could be obtained and so that the claimant could also receive further medical treatment. Matters culminated in the respondent attempting to arrange an occupational health assessment with the claimant who was unwilling to participate. Consequently, the respondent wrote to the claimant to state that as it was not possible to assess his fitness for a return to flying duties, the termination date would not be postponed any further.

The claimant brought a claim of unfair dismissal to the Employment Tribunal, but he was unsuccessful. The ET found that on 21st December 2018 there was very little to suggest that the claimant was able and willing to return to his role. The ET were satisfied that the respondent had reasonable grounds for its belief in the claimant’s incapacity. They found that the claimant’s absence affected the respondent’s staffing levels and that after two years of absence the impact would have been significant. The ET found that they were satisfied that the decision to dismiss was within the band of reasonable responses and therefore the dismissal was found to be fair.

The claimant appealed to the EAT citing that the ET failed to recognise that the respondent’s actions were not in accordance with their Absence Management Policy (AMP). The claimant argued that the ET should have asked itself whether a reasonable employer would have consistently amended the termination date which, it was alleged, was in breach of the AMP.

The EAT found that there was no breach of the AMP as it did not stop a manager from postponing the termination date. The EAT also found that it was clear from the ET judgment that there was no substantive unfairness to the claimant as each of the postponements were to his advantage. The claimant’s appeal against the ET finding therefore failed.

Whilst it should be very rare that a termination date is postponed, this case is a useful reminder of the key points to follow before dismissing an employee who has been on long term sickness absence. These include ascertaining the employee’s medical position, consulting with the employee, considering the availability of alternative employment, and considering how long it is reasonable for the employer to wait. A fair procedure taking into account any relevant policies should also be followed.  

Related articles

  • tribunal

    Blog

    HMRC refuses to stand down on £470k giant marshmallows case

    After losing a £470,000 VAT case at the Upper Tribunal over whether giant marshmallows are confectionery, HMRC is taking the fight to the Court of Appeal

    Peninsula TeamPeninsula Team
    • Employment Tribunal
  • working

    Blog

    Employers asked what help is most needed to get people back into work

    With the Government considering a number of welfare-to-work reforms, the Recruitment and Employment Confederation (REC) decided to ask employers for their views on what is most needed in order to find, recruit and retain the right people.

    Peninsula TeamPeninsula Team
    • Employment Contract
  • staff rates falling

    Blog

    April sees staff rates falling but pay growth on the up

    The latest KPMG and Recruitment and Employment Confederation (REC) report on UK jobs has found the number of workplaces is still slowly dropping while salaries are increasing

    Peninsula TeamPeninsula Team
    • Pay & Benefits
Back to resource hub

Try Brainbox for free today

When AI meets 40 years of Peninsula expertise... you get instant, expert answers to your HR and Health & Safety questions

Sign up to our newsletter

Get the latest news & tips that matter most to your business in our monthly newsletter.