Elon Musk: what HR lines has the Twitter CEO crossed?

  • End of Employment
Gavin Scarr-Hall - Director of Health & Safety at Peninsula

Gavin Scarr Hall, Director of Health and Safety

(Last updated )

Elon Musk told Twitter employees via email that they would need to commit to working ‘long hours at high intensity’ or ‘leave’ as part of his dramatic vision for Twitter 2.0.

In the company-wide email, Musk said that his revamped workforce would need to be ‘extremely hardcore’, and if they didn’t agree to the changes, their employment would end with three months of severance pay.

Earlier this month, he also made the controversial decision to dismiss key Twitter executives and almost 50% of full-time staff.

While HR rules differ in the US, Elon Musk’s management style would create huge legal headaches for UK employers. And here’s how…

1. Forced resignation could lead to constructive dismissal claims

By giving employees an ultimatum to accept new working conditions or leave, Musk is essentially forcing his staff to resign unless they accept his new terms.

Here in the UK, this would give employees grounds to claim for constructive dismissal. Employees can claim for constructive dismissal if they feel they have been forced to resign, like if they had to work in extreme or unmanageable conditions. 

Plus, if you want to change the terms of a contract, like working hours, you need to first:

  • check the contract has a flexibility clause – this gives employers a right to make ‘reasonable changes’ to some employment conditions
  • get consent from the employee or their union representative after a period of consultation
  • follow a fair and full dismissal process (like providing a valid reason, notice, and a right to appeal)
  • give the employee notice (statutory or the notice period in their contract, whatever’s longest)
  • wait until the dismissal and rehiring process is complete before making changes to employment conditions

2. Failure to consider vulnerable workers

Whilst Musk may have the power to change working hours or conditions, he fails to consider the impact this may have on vulnerable workers. For example, staff with childcare responsibilities may not be able to commit to working long hours.

It will likely seem ‘unreasonable’ in the eyes of the law to make a drastic change to working conditions. And if someone has to leave their job because their employer is forcing them to accept ‘unreasonable changes to their work’, they may be able to make a constructive dismissal claim.

Likewise, for staff who have health conditions, working long hours might go against medical advice. So, to dismiss them for not agreeing to longer hours could also result in disability discrimination claims.

3. Lack of communication

On Thursday 3rd November, Twitter employees received an email telling them there would be ‘mass layoffs’ announced the following day. They then had to wait to find out whether their job was safe or not.

This serious lack of communication goes against HR best practices completely. The unsuspecting email left Twitter employees clueless about their future. Many even reported that they didn’t hear the news from Musk or their manager. They just woke up to find themselves locked out of their company email accounts.

In a case of dismissal, communication is vital. Before terminating employment, employers should first complete a full and fair consultation process with employees and employee representatives.

Dismissal should be a final resort and it shouldn’t come as a surprise to the employee. Ideally, the employee should find out in a private meeting. And this should come after a full and fair procedure.  

Whilst communicating personally is more difficult when carrying out mass redundancies, UK employers would also need to be able to justify a fair reason and prove they had followed all the right steps. If they can’t do this, there would be huge legal consequences.

4. Making mass layoffs without the required notice period

In the UK, ‘collective redundancy’ rules would apply if terminating 20 or more employees’ jobs by reason of redundancy.

Which means if you’re making 20 or more workers redundant, you would need to carry out consultations in advance and provide written notice. This consultation period would be 30 days for up to 100 workers and 45 days for over 100 workers.

A group of former Twitter employees have since sued Elon Musk on the grounds that he failed to give the appropriate legal notice period. This is according to US law.

In the UK, failing to follow collective redundancy rules would lead to legal claims and fines.

5. The likelihood of staff burnout

Putting pressure on staff to be ‘hardcore’ and work intense hours is more likely to lead to burnout before success.

Whilst some employees may enjoy working under pressure, it’s not realistic to expect all staff to be at ‘peak performance’ every day.

Getting the best out of employees means supporting their wellbeing. If staff are exhausting themselves by working long hours, they’re likely to be less productive over time. It’s important to constantly review an employee’s workload and the deadlines being set to make sure they’re realistic.

An overworked and stressed employee is far more at risk of making mistakes and having mental and physical health issues. Eventually, they may even leave the job. If your goal is to retain staff, it’s important to make sure their wellbeing comes first.

Make staff wellbeing a priority

Help staff overcome their greatest challenges with an employee assistance programme.

Learn more

Let HR and health & safety experts guide you on the safest path to success…

When the future of your company is on the line, you may have to make difficult decisions. But in the pursuit of success, don’t forget the path is littered with legal pitfalls – or your journey could be cut short…

That’s where your HR and health & safety experts come in. They’ll guide you on the safest path to success, whilst helping you avoid traps along the way.

Whether it’s a simple contract query or a big challenge like redundancy, you have round-the-clock advice from HR experts. It means you’ll always do right by your staff. No risk. No time-wasting. Help is always a phone call away.

To get the answer to your queries today, call 0800 029 4384 for a free consultation with an industry-leading expert.

Related articles

  • employees sat at desk with laptops


    What can I do if my employee doesn’t want to work their notice?

    “My new employer needs me to start straight away. Is there any way we can waive my notice period?” What should you do if your employee resigns and doesn’t want to work their notice period? Well, you have a few options here…

    Kate PalmerHR Advice and Consultancy Director
    • End of Employment
  • Dismissal for refusing to install work app on personal phone was unfair, says ET


    Dismissal for refusing to install work app on personal phone was unfair, says ET

    An employment tribunal (ET) had to consider whether an employee had been unfairly dismissed after she refused to put a work-related app onto her personal phone.

    Peninsula Team Peninsula Team
    • Dismissal
  • Redundancy Period


    Poundland snaps up 71 Wilko stores

    Poundland owner Pepco has agreed to take on up to 71 Wilko stores, with staff working at the sites given priority for jobs once the sale has been completed.

    Peninsula TeamPeninsula Team
    • Redundancy
Back to resource hub

Try Brainbox for free today

When AI meets 40 years of Peninsula expertise... you get instant, expert answers to your HR and Health & Safety questions

Sign up to our newsletter

Get the latest news & tips that matter most to your business in our monthly newsletter.

International sites

© 2023 Peninsula Business Services Limited. Registered Office: The Peninsula, Victoria Place, Manchester, M4 4FB. Registered in England and Wales No: 1702759. Peninsula Business Services Limited is authorised and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority for the sale of non-investment insurance contracts.

Cyber Essential Logo
BAFE SP205 Registration
ISO 27001 and 9001 accredited company.
The Sunday Times - Top Track 250.
Glassdoor 2018 Best Places To Work.